Jesus Daniel Romero from the Miami Strategic Intelligence Institute for Poder & Dinero and FinGurú
Under the leadership of President Javier Milei, Argentina is making a strategic shift towards a trade agreement with the United States. This change significantly diverges from the country's traditional trade agreements within Mercosur. The Milei government has strongly supported a Free Trade Agreement (TFA) with the United States. Given the consensus requirement of the regional bloc for external trade agreements, this measure could imply leaving Mercosur if necessary.
Milei has openly criticized the Mercosur rule of unanimity, which he sees as an obstacle to Argentina's economic flexibility and its ability to negotiate advantageous trade terms independently. At the heart of this shift is the desire to reduce Argentina's dependence on regional trade agreements, particularly with Brazil, and to diversify its trading relationships to boost economic growth. The government's push for a trade deal with the United States aligns with broader efforts to strengthen Argentina's international position amid challenging economic conditions (Katz, 2023).
Mercosur and Argentina's Global Economic Integration
Argentina's possible exit from Mercosur poses significant considerations for regional trade dynamics. While leaving the bloc could enhance Argentina's ability to reach independent agreements with global powers like the United States, it would also disrupt trade relations with neighboring countries, especially Brazil. Argentina's trade with Brazil is substantial, and any disruption could significantly affect vital supply chains in key sectors (Santos, 2022).
Despite these risks, Milei has remained firm in his commitment to pushing for a trade agreement with the United States, even suggesting that Argentina could be the first country to adopt reciprocal trade terms similar to those promoted during Donald Trump's presidency. This pursuit reflects a broader desire to reduce Argentina's dependence on regional trade frameworks and integrate into the global economy on more favorable terms (López, 2023).
Economic Reforms and Milei's Free Market Vision
Milei's government has already implemented significant economic reforms to address Argentina's persistent fiscal challenges. These reforms have focused on austerity measures, inflation control, and budget deficit reduction, positioning Argentina for a potential recovery. Despite the short-term difficulties of these measures, investor confidence has been bolstered, and Milei's free market approach has garnered international support, including from figures like former U.S. President Donald Trump (Smith, 2022). By advancing a trade agreement with the U.S., Milei aims to consolidate Argentina's integration into global markets, allowing the country to benefit from greater access to the U.S. economy and its vast consumer market. Furthermore, such an agreement could foster higher-quality foreign direct investment, essential for driving Argentina's long-term economic growth (Peterson Institute, 2023).
Benefits for the United States
A Free Trade Agreement with Argentina would also significantly benefit the United States. As the second-largest economy in South America, Argentina represents a considerable market for U.S. exports. By negotiating a trade agreement, U.S. companies would gain preferential access to Argentine markets for goods and services, ranging from agricultural products to technology and manufacturing (Reichert, 2023).
Additionally, the United States benefits from diversifying its trade relationships in Latin America. While Brazil and Mexico remain important economic partners, strengthening ties with Argentina would offer the U.S. greater flexibility and strategic advantage in the region (Brown, 2022). Argentina's commitment to free market reforms further aligns with U.S. interests, reinforcing a shared vision of economic liberalization and market-driven policies (Smith, 2022).
A trade agreement could also create new opportunities for U.S. investment in Argentina's growing sectors, particularly energy, agriculture, and infrastructure. The market reforms implemented in Argentina under Milei’s administration make it an attractive destination for foreign direct investment (FDI), and U.S. companies would benefit from an improved business environment and the reduction of trade barriers. The potential for energy cooperation is particularly noteworthy, given Argentina's significant oil and gas reserves, which could help secure a more diversified energy supply for the United States (International Energy Agency, 2023).
Challenges to Achieving a Trade Agreement Before the Elections in Argentina
While the potential benefits of a Free Trade Agreement between the United States and Argentina are clear, the likelihood of achieving it before the elections in Argentina at the end of 2025 remains slim. Negotiating and finalizing trade agreements is often a lengthy process, and historical precedents suggest it could take years. For example, the Free Trade Agreement between the United States and Panama took approximately eight and a half years to materialize, while the agreement between the United States and Jordan was concluded in about a year and a half (Baker and O’Neill, 2021).
Recent statements from U.S. officials also suggest that there is currently little enthusiasm within the U.S. government for negotiating new FTAs, with a preference instead for promoting investment agreements (Miller, 2022). These factors further complicate the prospects of soon completing a comprehensive trade agreement with Argentina.
Impact on the Argentine Economy and the Hungarian Guide
Despite the difficulties in reaching a trade agreement before the upcoming elections, a Free Trade Agreement between the United States and Argentina could have a profound and stabilizing impact on the Argentine economy, particularly concerning its "Hungarian Guide," a term that refers to struggling economies with high inflation and debt problems (Johnson, 2022). A trade agreement with the United States would likely help Argentina boost its exports, reduce trade deficits, and attract foreign direct investment (FDI), especially in the energy, agriculture, and infrastructure sectors.
Such an agreement could help alleviate Argentina's persistent inflation issues by expanding market access and strengthening the country's fiscal position. A stronger economic base would generate more job opportunities and stabilize inflationary pressures, reducing the economy's vulnerability to external shocks. Furthermore, greater energy cooperation could secure Argentina's future energy supply, reducing costs and improving domestic production capacity (De la Torre and Gabaudan, 2023).
Additionally, with access to global markets and the potential for increased foreign investment, Argentina could diversify its economy and avoid excessive dependence on regional trade agreements and raw material exports, making it less vulnerable to economic downturns. This diversification would be crucial for addressing fiscal challenges and reducing Argentina's reliance on external debt (Reichert, 2023).
Impact on China's Regional Influence
A trade agreement between the United States and Argentina could significantly affect China's regional influence in Latin America. Argentina has long been a key partner for China, particularly in sectors like soybeans, oil, and infrastructure. If Argentina moves closer to the United States and strengthens its economic ties with this country, it could reduce its reliance on China for trade and investment, potentially transforming the economic landscape of Latin America.
China has heavily invested in Latin America through its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), financing large infrastructure projects in exchange for access to raw materials and strengthening its political influence. A trade agreement between the United States and Argentina could reduce Chinese investment, especially in infrastructure, as U.S. companies and capital begin to replace Chinese entities in the energy and manufacturing sectors. This could jeopardize China's growing regional presence (Cheng and Liu, 2023).
Moreover, Argentina's shift towards the United States could inspire other Latin American nations to reconsider their trade and investment relationships with China, favoring U.S.-backed agreements instead. This would represent a significant blow to China's regional strategy, as Latin America has been a focal point for Chinese geopolitical influence. While China will likely continue with its investments and trade relations in the region, Argentina's greater alignment with the United States could substantially weaken China's ability to assert its economic influence in the area (Zhang and Xu, 2022).
A Complex Balance: Trade, Reforms, and Regional Relationships
The pursuit of a trade agreement with the United States is not without its complexities. While the agreement could offer significant economic benefits, such as improved market access and an influx of investments, the decision to leave Mercosur presents risks that could undermine Argentina's regional relationships. The challenge will be to balance these risks with the long-term benefits of greater global integration.
In conclusion, Argentina's efforts to secure a trade agreement with the United States represent a radical shift in economic policy, reflecting the country's desire to open new avenues for growth and development. However, the way forward will require careful management of internal economic reforms and the broader regional trade landscape. As the global economy continues to evolve, Argentina's willingness to adapt and seek new trade opportunities will be key to determining its future economic trajectory. At the same time, the United States stands to benefit from greater market access, increased investment opportunities, and enhanced regional influence.
References
Baker, C. and O’Neill, B. (2021). U.S. Free Trade Agreements and Their Impact on Regional Trade Relations: A Historical Perspective. Global Trade Review, 14(2), 134-145.
Brown, M. (2022). U.S. Economic Interests in Latin America: The Strategic Turn Towards Argentina. Latin American Economic Journal, 25(3), 56-73.
Cheng, Y. and Liu, Z. (2023). China’s Role in Latin America: A Comprehensive Analysis of Trade and Investments Under the Belt and Road Initiative. Asia-Pacific Business Review, 18(1), 87-101.
De la Torre, A. and Gabaudan, B. (2023). Economic Reforms in Latin America: The Case of Argentina. Journal of Latin American Economics, 30(2), 209-224.
International Energy Agency. (2023). Energy Cooperation in Latin America: The Potential Role of Argentina in Global Energy Markets. IEA Reports, 7(1), 99-112.
Johnson, E. (2022). Inflation and Economic Instability in Argentina: Understanding the Effect of the Hungarian Guide. Journal of International Economics, 58(1), 15–32.
Katz, M. (2023). Argentina’s Shift Towards a U.S.-Centered Trade Policy: Opportunities and Challenges. The Americas Review, 33(4), 201–215.
López, R. (2023). Mercosur and Argentine Trade Policy: A Critical Crossroads. South American Economic Journal, 11(3), 44–60.
Miller, L. (2022). U.S. Trade Policy and Its Approach to Latin America in the 21st Century. American Foreign Policy Journal, 12(2), 88–104.
Peterson Institute. (2023). Foreign Direct Investment in Latin America: A New Wave of U.S. Capital in Argentina. Global Investment Insights, 7(2), 76–90.
Reichert, S. (2023). U.S. Trade Relations in Latin America: Strategic Implications of a U.S.-Argentina Free Trade Agreement. The Global Trade Journal, 21(2), 101–119.
Santos, M. (2022). The Economic Framework of Mercosur and Its Challenges: Lessons from Argentine Trade Policy. Mercosur Studies, 14(1), 45-58.
Smith, A. (2022). Market Reforms and the Future of the Argentine Economy. Economic Policy Studies, 8(3), 24–39.
Zhang, H. and Xu, F. (2022). The Growing Presence of China in Latin America: Implications for U.S. Influence. China-Latin America Research Journal, 5(1), 45–60.
U.S. State Department, U.S. Southern Command, Colonel Carl D. Springer, U.S. Army (Retired), Fox News TV, Tulsi Gabbard, Diario las Américas, The Epoch Times, The Epoch Times Español, Jesús Romero, William Acosta, Truth Social, innovation of President Donald J. Trump, One America News Network, América TeVé Miami, Miguel Cossio, Rolando Nápoles, Marian de la Fuente, Jorge Luis, SANCHEZ GRASS, ISABEL CUERVO, Naval Intelligence Office, U.S. Navy War College, Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Breitbart News, Infobae.
Major SIG®: Analytic, Strategic, and Geopolitical Intelligence Reports from the senior fellows of the Miami Strategic Intelligence Institute (MSI²). Follow us and subscribe on LinkedIn. For more information, visit www.miastrategicintel.com
Jesús Daniel Romero is Co-Founder and Senior Fellow at the Miami Strategic Intelligence Institute.
Retired Naval Intelligence Commander of the United States, with notable military and diplomatic service.
Author of the bestseller on Amazon "Final Flight: The Queen of Air," where he shares part of his experiences in the fight against drug trafficking in Central America
Comments